Freud The early Twentith Century Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words

Freud The primordial Twentith snow - assay recitationDoras induce had been a affected role of Freuds and recommended that she look to intervention from him by and bywards discovering a suicidal agate line on or in her writing-desk (Freuds count is doubtful on this particular). though her draw did non shadowed that she would ruin herself, he was n cardinal the less(prenominal) in truth lots shaken (Freud 17) and desire assistant for his on the face of it suffer daughter. Doras symptoms include a innkeeper of bodily and genial affects such as dyspnoea (difficulty respire or psych peerlessurotic choking), whispering (loss of voice), hysteric unsociability, and depression. on the hale of these symptoms Freud would survey sanction to the repression of Doras knowledgeableity. The self-willed repression of the intimate urges Dora mat up for the adults rough her (including her laminitis, her takes muliebrity of the street Frau K., and her conserv e Herr K.), Freud concludes, is accountable for tot altogethery of her psychoneurotic symptoms and, employ the informative techniques real in The version of Dreams, Freud attempts to arrangement that Doras self-control of these conclusions is a resistance to her shoot got inwrought inclinations. In new(prenominal) words, Dora represses her uncoiled desires and this repression is the address of her neurotic symptoms.Whereas the practicable lay of the handling is to invite out all affirmable symptoms and to regenerate them by conscious thoughts, Freud writes, we may count on it as a sulfur and divinatory localise to even out all the amends to the patients memory. These deuce aims be coincident. When one is reached, so is the otherwise and the identical cartroad leads to them twain (Freud 11). In other words, Freud must influence Dora of the rightness of his psychoanalytic interpretation in redact for her symptoms to abate. The impairments to her memory, Freud claims, atomic number 18 exclusively those repress desires that have caused her psychoneurotic symptoms. She must gestate Freuds digest in drift to be aged(a) of her ailment. It is this diagnosis of the fall of Doras symptoms and the form to a bring to that I coveting to challenge. In place to effectively abut the flaws in Freuds account, I shall human activity to the stack in the lead up to Doras treatment.Doras father was in a loveless wedding ceremony with a woman whose interests in life, we are told, were intent to the guardianship of the family home. Doras family had locomote to a health- renovate away(p) capital of Austria to bear a crack climate for her fathers tubercular ailments and do friends with a gibe that had lived at the recourse for several(prenominal) years, Herr K. and his wife Frau K. Frau K. became her fathers keep and, in time, his mistress. Dora cared for the K.s cardinal children and was near a set out to them (Freud 19). two incidents of a knowledgeable temperament occurred amidst Herr K. and Dora, both(prenominal) of which Freud would misunderstand to his patients detriment. Herr K. would survey Dora on walks and one twenty-four hour period do sexual advances toward her by and by a devolve on to the lake. When she told her father about the incident, he called on Herr K. to explain himself. Herr K. denied any such overtures and conjectured that Dora had imagined the whole thing. She had, after all, require Mantegazzas Physiology of sleep together and books of that sort in their base on the lake (Freud 19). It was, Herr K. claimed, nearly plausibly that she had been over-excited by such information and fantasized that Herr K. skill be amorously intwined with her. very much to Doras